Showing posts with label SmokeFree. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SmokeFree. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 09, 2009

Even More Monona City Council News

Aside from the festivities already described, the Monona city council also approved a 35% increase in the sewer rates, a $66 annual increase for the average sewer customer. Resolution 09-08-1644 Approving a Sanitary Sewer Rate Increase See my August 19 post for more details. Monona Council Report - Part Two

The council approved a "Smoking Area" Premise Extension For Tully’s II Food & Spirits, 6401 Monona Drive. The Hayes' submitted an improved and revised plan for an outdoor dining, drinking, and smoking area. Tully's II Smoking Area Premise Extension

The council also:

Passed a resolution of "Recommendation to the State of Wisconsin to Create a State Statute to Ban Handheld Use of Cell Phones and Text Messaging While Operating a Motor Vehicle" 09-09-1645 Recommendation to State to Ban Cell Phones While Driving .

Approved Participation in a Wisconsin Bureau of Transportation Safety Speed Enforcement 2010 Traffic Grant Resolution 09-09-1647, Participation in a 2010 Speed Enforcement Traffic Grant

Awarded a Contract for Project MO-02-09 Belle Isle Storm Water Lift Stations Resolution 09-09-1648, Award of Contract for Belle Isle Storm Water Lift Station

Passed a resolution Permitting Left Turns Onto Monona Drive From Owen Road.

***
Discussed:

Consideration of Substitute Resolution 09-09-1646 Approval of Police Canine Unit Policy, Authorization to Establish a Canine Unit and to Solicit Donations to Fund a Police K-9 Unit Resolution 09-09-1646 Regarding a Police Canine Unit The revised policy would require 'reasonable suspicion' before the dog could be deployed on a drug sniff during a routine traffic stop.

Awarding a contract for 2010 street engineering design to Vierbicher. A principal in the D'Onfrio Kottke firm made an appearance and made a strong case that the contract should be awarded to his firm. Resolution 09-09-1649, Design & Construction Engineering Services for 2010 Street/Utility Improvements

Creation of a Monona Drive Façade Improvement Program (city matching grant of up to $10,000) Resolution 09-09-1650, Approval to Initiate Monona Dr. Facade Improvement Program

***

The council also approved a number of minor ordinance amendments:

Ordinance 08-09-599, Regulating the Use of Skateboards & In-Line Skates
Ordinance 08-09-604, Amending Code Regarding Prohibiting Theft
Ordinance 08-09-606, Amending Code Concerning Vehicle Equipment Standards
Ordinance 08-09-607, Prohibiting False Complaint of Police Misconduct

Sunday, May 31, 2009

Eat, Drink and Breathe Free

Reminder: Monona goes smoke free tomorrow, June 1.

Word comes from Jim Shropshire that Breathe Free Monona is sponsoring a little event at the BW3s (Buffalo Wild Wings Grill & Bar - www.buffalowildwings.com 6544 Monona Dr, Monona) from 5:30-8:30 tomorrow evening (June 1).

Join them to celebrate the ordinance, and support our local businesses. BFM plans to have monthly events at a newly smoke free establishment on the 2nd Wednesday of each month as well.

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Plan Commission Update

Last evening, the Monona Plan Commission considered the ordinance to allow the keeping of chickens as well as several beer gardens that implicate the smokefree ordinance.

The meeting started at 5 pm with the showing of the Mad City Chickens movie.

The Plan Commission heard from numerous citizens in support of the ordinance and then had a full discussion of the proposed chicken keeping ordinance. The committee ultimately tabled consideration to its next meeting. It was a pretty good discussion overall. One possible amendment that I would not favor would require approval from one's immediate neighbors as a condition of approval.

In the meantime, I have requested a formal legal opinion from the city attorney (request has to approved by either the Mayor or city administrator) as to the current legal status of chicken keeping.

***

I left at that point but am informed that the Plan Commission approved the Tully's II outdoor patio and what amounts to a smoking room at the Bridge Lounge. For the full story see the Herald's report by Adam Mella at Additions approved for Tully's II and Bridge Lounge.


For a full preview (with links to the committee packet) see my earlier posting: Important Monona Plan Commission Meeting

Wednesday, April 08, 2009

Important Monona Plan Commission Meeting

On Monday, April 13, the Monona Plan Commission will take up several items of interest, especially to persons interested in chicken keeping and also the implementation of the smoke free ordinance with respect to 'outdoor' areas.

Tully's II proposes basically an open air patio. Bridge Lounge proposes a more enclosed smoking area, and the Village Lanes bowling alley proposal is yet more enclosed. Tully's II and the Bridge Lounge are on for decision. Village Lanes is making its initial appearance.

Plan Commission Meeting 4/13/09
Monday, April 13, 2009 at 7:00 PM

April 13, 2009 Plan Commission Agenda

Proposed Draft Ordinance Amendment for the Keeping of Chickens

Tully's II Proposed Outdoor Patio Area Plans

Bridge Lounge Addition of an Area for Smoking and Alcohol Consumption Plans

Village Lanes Proposed Attached Smoking Area Plans

Friday, March 06, 2009

Statewide Smoking Ban in the Budget - For Now

Governor Doyle included a comprehensive statewide indoor smoking ban in his executive state budget. The smoking ban would go into effect three months after passage of the budget. Given that the governor and both houses are all controlled by the same party, the word is that the state budget will pass early this year - possibly in May.

I am reliably informed, however, that the smoking ban will almost certainly be removed before the budget makes its way to passage. The smoking ban would then be introduced as a separate bill.

Here is a link to SmokeFree Wisconsin's blog. Here is their new web site It's Time Wisconsin.

Thursday, October 16, 2008

Was I at Those Meetings??

As reported (Plan Commission asks for changes at Watercrest, clarification on beer gardens) in this week's Herald Independent, the Monona Plan Commission is currently reviewing proposed revisions to the city's beer garden ordinance. I was not at the Plan Commission meeting, but I was at the License Review Committee (LRC) meetings (I chair that committee) when we reviewed this proposed ordinance. After reading the Herald report I have to set the record straight on a couple points.

First, the LRC took up this proposed revision to provide guidance to bar and restaurant owners who want to provide outdoor areas for patrons to eat, drink, and smoke. The proposed ordinance would remove the current requirement that a licensed bartender be present on the outdoor patio at all times, a requirement that struck me and the LRC as unduly burdensome and unnecessary. I want to remove that requirement.

We want to create a fair and reasonable ordinance that provides clear guidance for the creation of outdoor patio areas without creating a backdoor to circumvent the indoor smoking ordinance. That's why the draft requires that at least 30% of any enclosure be open to allow for the circulation of air.

The draft ordinance approved by the LRC did not prohibit the use of a screened porch as an outdoor alcohol consumption area. The reference to 'screening' was added by staff after the LRC review.


And in point of fact, the LRC did ask staff to look at regulations in Madison and Fitchburg and we were informed that neither city has any ordinance regulating what kind of structures can be built for these outdoor areas.

(Madison does allow for a "smoking room in a restaurant which is separately ventilated from each and every other area of the restaurant". That Madison ordinance runs entirely contrary to the entire point of the indoor smoking ordinance and in any event does not apply to outdoor areas.)

Stay tuned for further developments.

Thursday, June 19, 2008

Lance Armstrong Gives Monona the Yellow Jersey

Lance Armstrong on Wisconsin smoking bans.....


Wisconsinites must put up strong fight against smoking

By LANCE ARMSTRONG
June 10, 2008

I had the privilege of returning to Wisconsin for the Trek 100 last weekend. Being in Wisconsin always makes me think about how important Waterloo-based Trek has been to my cycling career for more than 10 years. The Wisconsin-built bikes helped me win seven Tour de France titles and bring excitement and attention to the cycling world. And I’m grateful that I can now help focus that attention on a cause even more vital to me: the war against cancer. My full-time job these days is the work of the Lance Armstrong Foundation - supporting cancer survivors and working to make cancer a national priority. And the state of Wisconsin has an opportunity to score a major victory in this fight and save countless lives.


I’m not a native of Wisconsin, nor do I pretend to be anything more than a humble visitor to your state. I speak as a two-term member of the President’s Cancer Panel, a sworn opponent of this disease and a father who wants kids in Wisconsin to have the same protection from secondhand smoke that my three children enjoy in Austin, Texas. I believe the choice facing the people of this great state is a life or death one that will affect generations to come.


When I last visited Wisconsin in March, I was honored to join Gov. Jim Doyle in speaking to a group of more than 1,000 enthusiastic and determined citizens from all walks of life, from all over the state, all in support of a statewide smoke-free bill. At the time, the Breathe Free Wisconsin Act had passed committees in both houses with strong bipartisan support but unfortunately, lawmakers never got the chance to vote on it. The bill was held hostage by a small handful of legislators until the session ended.


I believe this was just a temporary setback and I’m proud to see that the people of Wisconsin are not letting it slow them down.


Since my last visit, the cities of Eau Claire, Marshfield and Monona have passed smoke-free ordinances giving 90,000 more Wisconsin citizens protection from the dangers of secondhand smoke. The city of Middleton is lining up to do the same. And nearly 70 percent of Wisconsin voters support the idea of a smoke-free state; 78 percent think it’ll pass soon.
Here’s why that’s so important: Secondhand smoke is deadly. In Wisconsin, close to 4,000 people are diagnosed with lung cancer each year, more than half of whom die from the disease. What’s worse, lung cancer - while more deadly than breast, colon and prostate cancer combined - is almost entirely preventable. Eighty percent of all lung cancers are caused by smoking, both firsthand and secondhand.


Some say that customers who want to avoid exposure to this hazard shouldn’t go to establishments where smoking is allowed. But what about the employees at those businesses, the hard-working men and women who have to earn a living to support their families? Don’t they have a right to be protected?


I am proud to join the majority of people in this state in support of a historic and life-saving effort. Momentum is building, time is of the essence and I’m confident Wisconsin will reach the finish line.


(Lance Armstrong is a champion cyclist, a cancer survivor and founder and chairman of the Lance Armstrong Foundation.)

Bandwagon Effect

Hey, hey, ho, ho, that indoor smoke has got to go....

Sorry, a little flashback.

News comes across the teletype that the Dane County Board Supervisors are taking up a smoking ban ordinance for the unincorporated areas in the county. The county ordinance would take effect 90 days after publication.

Channel 3000 reports that "the proposal is expected to go through several committees and if passed this fall, businesses would have 90 days to go smoke-free.

A related resolution urges other communities in the county to adopt smoking bans that would go into effect by June 1, 2009 (same date as the Monona ordinance).

Dane County Smoking Ban Proposed Ordinance Amendment (PDF)

Thursday, May 29, 2008

Smoking Ban Coming to Monona in June 2009

Addendum May 30, 2008: After some reportedly spirited discussion, the Monona ad hoc smoking ban committee recommended adoption of a comprehnesive smoking ban ordiancne effective June 1, 2009 by a 6-0 vote last night.

In case you missed the news:

"Mayor Robb Kahl and a citizens' group both said today that June 2009 is acceptable. Kahl had wanted the ban to start in 2010 and Breath Free Monona had been pushing for November 2008."

Deal would ban smoking in Monona in 2009

Not everyone is happy; in fact, everyone is at least a little unhappy - almost always a sign of a good compromise. Kudos to the Mayor and the Breathe Free leadership.

Thursday, May 15, 2008

Monona Smoking Ban Brief

The Monona ad hoc smoking ban committee met for three and a half hours tonight. In brief, the committee voted to move its recommended smoking ban implementation date up to June 1, 2009. The vote was 4-0 with one abstention (Mitch Marks). Voting in favor were alder Kathy Thomas, alder Bob Miller, Mary Possin and Greg Meyers. Committee member Harold Polzer was excused to attend a funeral.

The committee used the Breath Free Monona proposed ordinance as a template and spent most of the night reviewing and tweaking it. The committee members deserve the community's thanks - otherwise this is truly a thankless job. I think most everyone on the committee and council feels squeezed between competing and inelastic demands.

I hope to have the full ordinance - as tweaked - to post in the next day or so. It is still a work-in-progress. The committee will meet on May 29 and make a recommendation to the council for its June 2 meeting.

Saturday, May 10, 2008

Breathe Free Monona Meeting

It is now virtually certain that a comprehensive smoking ban will become law in Monona. Indeed, there are now two competing smoking ban proposals. The proposals are likely to be very similar (we don't have the details of the ad hoc committee's recommendation yet), except for the implementation date. The referendum ban would would go into effect on November 14, 2008. As reported here Smoking Ban Committee Update, the ad hoc committee's recommended implementation date is October 1 , 2010.

The Breathe Free Monona group met this afternoon (May 10, 2008) at the Monona Community Center. (Even though this meeting was not technically a public meeting and they paid for the room, the Breathe Free Monona group was kind enough to allow nonmembers to attend, including Bob Miller and I as well as a couple of business owner opponents.) The group discussed the particulars of their proposal and kicked off its petition drive to place a binding referendum, also known as direct legislation (see, sec. 9.20 Wisconsin Statutes), on the November 2008 ballot.

The proposed ordinance creates a comprehensive ban on smoking in indoor public places, but does allow an exception for a tobacco bar. The ban would go into effect upon publication pursuant to s. 9.20 "within 10 days after the election". In other words, the referendum ban, if it gets on the ballot and passes would go into effect on November 14, 2008.

The group has 60 days to gather the signatures of "at least 15% of the votes cast for governor at the last general election" or 642 signatures. (Monona had 4276 votes cast in the last governor's election). The expectation is that the group will gather the signatures in much less 60 days.

Dane County Fall election results for 2006 http://www.co.dane.wi.us/coclerk/elect2006d.html

Once the petitions are submitted the city clerk has 15 days to "determine by careful examination whether the petition is sufficient and whether the proposed ordinance or resolution is in proper form" and certify those results to the city council. The city council then has thirty days to either adopt the ordinance or submit to the voters.

However, direct legislation may not be used to amend or repeal an existing ordinance if that ordinance is adopted prior to the clerk's certification. See, Mount Horeb Community Alert v. Village Board of Mt. Horeb, 2003 WI 100, 263 Wis. 2d 544, 665 N.W.2d 229, 01−2217. Thus, if the city council adopts a smoking ban ordinance before the clerk certifies the signatures, then the referendum could not be held.

Alder Bob Miller stated today that he expects the ad hoc committee will hold two more meetings (May 15 and May 29) before making a recommendation to the council. The recommendation could come to the council at the first meeting in June and possibly be voted on at the second June meeting. My guess is that the referendum petitions will have been submitted and certified before the council acts. (It is not clear whether the council could still adopt a smoking ban ordinance pending the referendum although the referendum results would take precedence).

(BTW, to squelch a crazy rumor floating around town, neither this ordinance nor the one originally drafted by Peter McKeever and myself would prohibit smoking in private residences.)

It is rather amazing to see how the landscape has changed in a short period of time. Alder McKeever and I had talked about bringing up a smoking ban proposal for some time, but didn't do so until late February 2008 in part because it was very unclear what its fate would be. I don't think either of us ever imagined that we would end up with two competing proposals for a comprehensive smoking ban.

The public health benefits of a smoking ban are real, large, and nearly immediate. See two studies of the health benefits in Helena, Montana and Pueblo, Colorado. Helena enjoyed a 40% drop in hospital admissions for heart attacks (compared to the same six-month period from the year before) while nearby communities without bans experienced no changes in heart attack rates. Pueblo Hospital admissions for acute heart attacks dropped 27% for the one and a half year period after the ban compared to the same time frame prior to the ban. [See, Sargent et al (2004) BMC, vol. 328, pages 977-980 and Bartecchi et al (2006) Circulation, vol. 114, pages 1490-1496].

Helena study: http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/328/7446/977
Pueblo study: http://circ.ahajournals.org/cgi/reprint/114/14/1490
Editorial: http://circ.ahajournals.org/cgi/reprint/114/14/1450.pdf

Neither proposal is ideal. The ad hoc committee recommendation would delay these significant public health improvements in Monona for nearly two and a half years. The referendum initiative, however, would implement the ban so quickly that businesses will not have enough time to change their business plans, get city approvals for outdoor smoking areas or beer gardens, obtain the capital to make the changes, and actually makes the changes. For what it's worth, I would like to see the council adopt a comprehensive ordinance with an implementation date in mid-2009 that would possibly give businesses actually within the Monona Drive construction zone until October 2010. But my guess is that the referendum initiative will be certified for the ballot before the council gets to vote on it.

Friday, May 09, 2008

Breathe Free Monona Forms To Seek Referendum

I received this announcement that a local group has formed to put a smoking ban ordinance on the ballot. Here is the message unedited (except bold lettering added).

Dear all:

For those of you that I haven't met, I am a physician that lives in Monona and I am passionate about getting Monona smoke free, I wanted to personally welcome you all to this effort and let you know what was decided at the last meeting on Wednesday night. First, Jim Keck and I have agreed to be co-chairs to lead this effort. A big thank you to Liz Sanger from Smoke Free Wisconsin and Ryan Sheehan from UW Public health and Tobacco Free Dane County Coalition who have pledged support and their advice has been invaluable!

It was also decided at the meeting to move forward with collecting signatures with a goal of around 800. We chose to move quickly given the city council ad hoc committee's intention to draft and present an ordinance to the city council delaying making Monona smoke-free for at least 2 1/2 years, and possibly longer (due to construction never ending on time). If the ordinance is passed before we collect the 800 signatures, we will NOT be able to submit a referendum. The ad hoc committee plans to present this drafted ordinance in the near future. So time is of the essence. We also changed the name of our group to Breathe Free Monona to take advantage of some preprinted materials available to us now.

To this end, we organized a meeting to train petitioners for THIS Saturday 5/10 11:30-12:30 in the lounge room of the Monona community center. Free lunch will be provided by Smoke Free Wisconsin and the American Cancer Society. The intent is to distribute the petition signature sheets and train people on the responses to common questions. People can then go out to neighborhoods and collect signatures. We hope to collect the required amount within one week so we can get our referendum on the ballot this Fall.

I would ask you all to invite any Monona residents who you know who may be willing to collect signatures to this meeting.

Best Regards, Theresa

Theresa Guilbert, MD
Assistant Professor of Pediatrics
Pediatric Pulmonary Section
University of Wisconsin-Madison

Saturday, May 03, 2008

Smoking Ban Committee Update

The ad hoc smoking ban committee met Thursday night and got input from bar owners and residents. I was not there so this report is based on city administrator Patrick Marsh's verbal report to me. Errors, if any, are likely my fault.

The committee did approve a recommended smoking ban implementation date of October 1, 2010 by a 5-0 vote with an abstention by Mitch Marks of the Silver Eagle.

I hope to have more details later.

Friday, April 18, 2008

Ad Hoc Smoking Ban Committee Meets

The Monona ad hoc Smoking Ban Committee met for the first time last night. A civil and productive discussion was had and much progress was made.

Two members stated their clear preference for a smoking ban (Mary Possin and Alder Bob Miller), two members stated their clear opposition (bar owners Mitch Marks of the Silver Eagle and Greg Meyers of BW3). Alder Kathy Thomas stated she thought a local ban was inevitable and that a referendum drive is likely to occur if the committee does not produce a reasonable and timely recommendation to the council. Member Harold Polzer (absent due to a longstanding other commitment) has previously stated his support for a smoking ban. In other words, it looks very likely that the committee will recommend a broad indoor smoking ban.

In the audience were a reporter from the Herald Independent, a rep from the American Cancer Society, Ryan Sheahan of Tobacco Free Dane County (Welcome to Tobacco Free Dane County Coalition, Inc.) and yours truly.

All members, including the two tavern keepers stated their support and preference for a statewide ban. Hear that, Tavern League?

The discussion then turned to 'assuming that there will be a smoking ban ordinance, what should it look like?' Interestingly, Greg Meyers said he would not want any exceptions, such as Fitchburg has for small taverns and the bowling center that get an extra two or three years. Others thought that a tobacco bar, like the Monona Tasting Room should be exempted.

The implementation date remains the biggest issue left the most unresolved. Some argued that implementation should not occur before the end of the first phase of Monona drive reconstruction - late 2010....

Hanging around in the background, of course, is the possibility of a binding referendum or direct legislation. See section 9.20 Stats. http://www.legis.state.wi.us/statutes/Stat0009.pdf

The next meeting is scheduled for 7:00 p.m. on May 1, location TBD. I take the early meeting date as another good sign that the committee will produce a recommendation to the council sooner rather than later.

The committee decided to specifically invite restaurant and tavern owners to the next meeting for their input as to what a smoking ban ordinance should contain. My knee-jerk reaction was I didn't like this approach. I changed my mind when I recalled that as Chair of the License Review Committee I had directed staff to do the same thing when we were discussing our unusual 'cover up the beer' after 9 PM law. Why? Those are the folks most directly impacted. The difference here is that the smoking ban is an issue with great public interest. I emphasize, however, that the license holders are being invited to talk about the details of smoking ban ordinance and not to state their opposition to such a ban.

Anyone is free to attend and speak, of course. If you do choose to come, just remember the committee wants to hear what the ordinance should look like and not whether you support or oppose the ban.

Sunday, April 06, 2008

Study Links OWI and Smoking Bans

The Cap Times reported on a UW-Milwaukee study linking local Wisconsin smoking bans with increased OWI's. Study links smoking bans to OWIs

Yawn. I reported evidence supporting such linkage about three weeks ago: OWI Arrests Spike After Madison SmokeFree Law - Updated

Monona is in the unusual situation where Madison's ban has made our local bars smokier and also (probably) increased the incidence of drunk driving. To be clear, the idea is that on average people are driving farther to drink in Monona where they can smoke while they drink and consequently are at a greater risk of apprehension when they make the return trip after drinking (and smoking).

Just wondering out loud: Why doesn't the Dane County Board of Supervisors take up a county-wide smoking ban? That would be an improvement over a patchwork of local laws.

Stub Your Butt


Bans on public indoor smoking are gaining momentum. Marshfield voters approve smoke-free referendum by a 2 - 1 margin!

Fitchburg's smoke-free ordinance implemented April 1

And Minnesota is making fun of us with a billboard on I-94 near Hudson. (If anyone can find a photo of this billboard, let me know - I googled my fingers off with no luck).


The voters in Marshfield passed a binding referendum. Here is the wording of the referendum question in Marshfield. Is a referendum vote in Monona's future?


Take note that the Marshfield wording only allows very limited exceptions, a necessity in order to have a concise question.


Question 1: Prohibit Smoking in Indoor Places"Should the Common Council of the City of Marshfield, Wisconsin, prohibit smoking in indoor places including any indoor place that is a place of employment or that is open to the public or to which members of the public may be invited or have lawful access, but does not apply to a private residence, a room used by a person in a retirement home as a private residence or a room in a lodging establishment that has been designated as a room where smoking is allowed?"

Sunday, March 16, 2008

OWI Arrests Spike After Madison SmokeFree Law - Updated

The Monona Police Department 2006 Annual Report shows that on OWI arrests in Monona increased 289% in the first full year after after the Madison smokefree ordinance went into effect. (effective date July 1, 2005). (All OWI citations result in an arrest.) Update: Chief Ostrenga provided 2007 number of 151 OWI arrests - a 215% increase over 2004. He also suggested that turnover in the Department, possibly including his own hiring in late 2004, may have led to higher enforcement activity.

Monona OWI Arrests by Year
2004 70
2005 149 Madison ordinance goes into effect at exactly mid-year
2006 202
2007 151

It is quite likely that some of the increase was due to a change in enforcement The report states the Department engaged in "the traffic grant project 'DETER', the goal of which was to reduce the number of speeding and OWI violations on the beltline."

I don't have the 2007 numbers yet or the exact details on when the Department participated in DETER, but this huge increase in OWI arrests is at least highly suggestive that tavern revenues weren't the only thing brought to Monona by the Madison smoking ban.

Saturday, March 15, 2008

Mayor Nominates Ad Hoc SmokeFree Committee

Mayor Kahl's nominees for the ad hoc smokefree committee are on the agenda for next Monday:

1. Kathy Thomas to the Ad Hoc Committee Considering a Non-Smoking Ordinance.
2. Bob Miller to the Ad Hoc Committee Considering a Non-Smoking Ordinance.
3. Mary Possin to the Ad Hoc Committee Considering a Non-Smoking Ordinance.
4. Greg Meyers to Ad Hoc Committee Considering a Non-Smoking Ordinance.
5. Mitch Marks to the Ad Hoc Committee Considering a Non-Smoking Ordinance.
6. Harold Polzer to the Ad Hoc Committee Considering a Non-Smoking Ordinance.

Greg Meyers is a partner in the BW3 restaurant and Mitch Marks is owner of the Silver Eagle
You can also access the agenda and supporting documents on the city's web site: Click Here for Agenda and Supporting Documents

Friday, March 07, 2008

Smoke, Smoke, Smoke That Cigarette

From the Internal Inconsistency Department, many of smokefree Monona opponents argues that they supported a statewide ban, but then turned around and made the phony 'choice' argument. As I've written before, this choice is really a smoker's veto. Besides which, smokers create a public health hazard when the light up in a public indoor space - and then wrap themselves in the Constitution.

Anyway, the Herald's wonderful, mahvelous columnist Sunny Schubert took the same line this week on the smokefree ordinance. She seemed to support a statewide law, but then chastised Peter McKeever and I for trying to take the smoker's choice away from an elderly resident. The unnamed elder and Sunny could smoke all they want under the ordinance, just not in a public indoor space where they expose others to the health hazards of their habit.

Here's a thought, let's expand this smoker's choice: how about smoking and nonsmoking elevators? Doctor's offices? Taxis? Buses?

By the way, the Mayor made much of the purported fact that alder McKeever and I are not business owners and therefore....what, I'm not sure. I'm not a senior (really, not yet - I'm barely AARP-eligible!), but I vote on issues concerning seniors, I don't ride the bus, but I chair Transit, etc.

In any event, Peter actually is a small business owner (his law practice). The other supporter of the proposal, Bob Miller, is not only a small business owner, but has an interest in the Great Dane Pub - Great Dane Pub. On the other hand, to my knowledge - and I could be wrong - none of three alders opposing the ordinance as proposed are small business owners.

On the other hand, we all breathe.

Anyway, keep an eye on who the Mayor appoints to the Ad Hoc committee. I know that Jim Keck has agreed to serve if appointed. It's hard to imagine anyone more qualified. Jim is an assistant professor in Biomolecular Chemistry and teaches course at the UW medical school, a member of the Paul P. Carbone Comprehensive Cancer Center, and an American Cancer Society Research Scholar. (He supports the ordinance).

Monday, March 03, 2008

Smoking Ban Referred to Ad Hoc Committee

At tonight's meeting, the Monona City Council referred the proposed smoking ban ordinance to an ad hoc committee for review and recommendation. The committee will consist of seven members, probably including two alders, some bar owners, and some supporters of the ban.

Prior to this action, the council heard from about 35-40 speakers, including about 18-20 bar owners or tavern-industry related representatives. The Tavern League knows how to get the crowd out on short notice. Not surprisingly, they were unanimous in opposing the ban. There were 3 or 4 residents not connected to the tavern business who opposed the ban. There were about 10 or so residents who supported the ban and a few health professionals.

The council had a 'discussion' that got a little testy at times, but not too bad. To a great extent the opponents and proponents talked past each other. The opponents raised valid concerns about potential harm to businesses and bogus claims to 'free choice'. The proponents talked mostly about the large negative health aspects of secondhand smoke. Proponents did offer that numerous studies have shown that the net overall economic impact of smokefree laws is neutral or positive. Of course, that doesn't mean that individual businesses won't successfully adapt and will be hurt.

One thing that became clear - and this information came as much from the bar owners as anyone else - is the great extent to which Monona has already become a 'smoking island' after the Madison ordinance. Query: Would you rather be a smoking island or a smokefree island?

The 'choice' argument is bogus in a couple respects. It is not a legitimate 'choice' for business owners to operate their business in a way that they know causes significant harm to their customers and employees. That sounds more like intentional infliction of harm to me. Second, when consumers make the 'choice' to smoke in a public place they exercise an effective 'smoker's veto' over the rights of nonsmokers who want to avoid exposure to carcinogens and increased risk of heart disease. People who are at risk for heart disease are already advised to stay away from exposure to tobacco smoke. When the smoker lights up their 'choice' takes precedence over the interests of all others.

I think we moved the smokefree argument forward in one way or another. We got it on the public agenda. If nothing else perhaps we have encouraged our state senator to make pushing the state ban a high priority.

And on we go to the ad hoc committee. Keep an eye on who gets appointed and the pace of progress (or lack of same). If you support the smoking ban, then you need to be vigilant because the bar owners and the Tavern League will most certainly be there looking out for their economic interests. Vigilance is the price of clean air.